philbertr (Hurricane Target Florida) | | Posted: Oct 11, 2007 - 04:50 | |
Its a beautiful song in its own right, and Sarah has a beautiful voice. Why not? I'd say the result is lovely.
|
|
pushkinjim (Sweden) | | Posted: Oct 11, 2007 - 04:50 | |
I like Sarah, but not this. Keep to the original.
|
|
ambliance (Off the 'Vine) | | Posted: Aug 09, 2007 - 08:37 | |
I like her natural, casual style on this. Just hanging out on the back porch or by the fireplace sharing one of her favorites with friends.
|
|
sutcliff (Saint Louis) | | Posted: Aug 09, 2007 - 08:15 | |
Song....I like. The film really did not make an impression.
|
|
Pyro
| | Posted: Aug 09, 2007 - 08:15 | |
gormeister wrote:yikes. not even close. let the original be.
I don't normally care for Beatles covers, but I like this. She has a lovely voice, IMHO.
Takes all kinds, eh? |
|
DoctorHooey (/etc) | | Posted: Aug 09, 2007 - 08:12 | |
|
gormeister (Commonwealth of Virginia) | | Posted: Jul 08, 2007 - 19:23 | |
yikes. not even close. let the original be.
|
|
jojopodo
| | Posted: Jun 07, 2007 - 11:55 | |
daliebe wrote:Well, I've been dying to share my Sarah story somewhere. RP is as good a place as any.
I saw Sarah in concert in '04 and of all the performers I've seen she seemed the most, well, real. Humble. Generous. Personable. Her connection with the audience was so great that even though I was in the middle of Staples Center I felt like I was watching her perform in a small venue. |
|
ChardRemains (Pepperland) | | Posted: Jun 07, 2007 - 11:20 | |
Geecheeboy wrote:...Nice clean pickin too. Better than MY version for sure. Yeah, takes a little more work than it appears at first. |
|
tapatia (Over the hills and far away...) | | Posted: Jun 07, 2007 - 11:11 | |
daliebe wrote:Well, I've been dying to share my Sarah story somewhere. RP is as good a place as any.
My wife and I were flying to Tofino, B.C. for a winter holiday. The airport (really just a little strip of pavement surrounded by forest) was fogged in and our pilot told us we had to land on the other side of the mountain range.
Sarah's flight had also been diverted; she was coming home after performing a tsunami relief concert in Calgary. She looked totally bagged, and had her young daughter with her. She spoke on her cell, telling her husband "I'll just rent a car and get there in a couple hours."
"Hi, I'm David," I said to her. "My name's Sarah," she answered. Well, duh.
I asked if we could share a vehicle with her and she was glad to. It meant she could sit in the back and tend to her daughter who got car sick on the twisty road. Just your everyday pop star with puke on her jacket.
What if I accidentally drive off a cliff? I thought morbidly. That would make me the rock equivalent of Buddy Holly's pilot. Not something I've ever aspired to.
We arrived at the "airport" where her husband was waiting for her. He walked towards Sarah, veered with a startled look towards my wife and gave HER a big hug. Turns out they'd gone to high school together.
And there you go. Nothing dramatic. Not even any photographic proof to my friends who have cried "bullshit." But it's my favourite brush-with-fame story, made all the more wonderful for just how completely normal it all seemed.
Talk about six degress of separation! What a great story. |
|
YourNameHere (Los Angeles) | | Posted: May 07, 2007 - 01:52 | |
daliebe wrote:Well, I've been dying to share my Sarah story somewhere. RP is as good a place as any.
Great story-- now that's something that would never happen in Los Angeles. I see "stars" all the time at LAX. Offering to share a ride would probably get you shot by one of their handlers. |
|
davin (Victoria, British Columbia) | | Posted: Apr 05, 2007 - 12:12 | |
Hey, nice story :)
daliebe wrote:Well, I've been dying to share my Sarah story somewhere. RP is as good a place as any.
My wife and I were flying to Tofino, B.C. for a winter holiday. The airport (really just a little strip of pavement surrounded by forest) was fogged in and our pilot told us we had to land on the other side of the mountain range.
Sarah's flight had also been diverted; she was coming home after performing a tsunami relief concert in Calgary. She looked totally bagged, and had her young daughter with her. She spoke on her cell, telling her husband "I'll just rent a car and get there in a couple hours."
"Hi, I'm David," I said to her. "My name's Sarah," she answered. Well, duh.
I asked if we could share a vehicle with her and she was glad to. It meant she could sit in the back and tend to her daughter who got car sick on the twisty road. Just your everyday pop star with puke on her jacket.
What if I accidentally drive off a cliff? I thought morbidly. That would make me the rock equivalent of Buddy Holly's pilot. Not something I've ever aspired to.
We arrived at the "airport" where her husband was waiting for her. He walked towards Sarah, veered with a startled look towards my wife and gave HER a big hug. Turns out they'd gone to high school together.
And there you go. Nothing dramatic. Not even any photographic proof to my friends who have cried "bullshit." But it's my favourite brush-with-fame story, made all the more wonderful for just how completely normal it all seemed. |
|
eastcoast
| | Posted: Apr 05, 2007 - 12:11 | |
I actually like ti better than Pauls version...lets face it this not a Beatle song but a Paul song.
|
|
meydele (By the sea) | | Posted: Apr 05, 2007 - 12:11 | |
daliebe wrote:And there you go. Nothing dramatic. Not even any photographic proof to my friends who have cried "bullshit." But it's my favourite brush-with-fame story, made all the more wonderful for just how completely normal it all seemed.
And quite a nice story it is. |
|
driver8 (seuls au monde) | | Posted: Apr 05, 2007 - 12:10 | |
daliebe wrote:Well, I've been dying to share my Sarah story somewhere. RP is as good a place as any.
My wife and I were flying to Tofino, B.C. for a winter holiday. The airport (really just a little strip of pavement surrounded by forest) was fogged in and our pilot told us we had to land on the other side of the mountain range.
Sarah's flight had also been diverted; she was coming home after performing a tsunami relief concert in Calgary. She looked totally bagged, and had her young daughter with her. She spoke on her cell, telling her husband "I'll just rent a car and get there in a couple hours."
"Hi, I'm David," I said to her. "My name's Sarah," she answered. Well, duh.
I asked if we could share a vehicle with her and she was glad to. It meant she could sit in the back and tend to her daughter who got car sick on the twisty road. Just your everyday pop star with puke on her jacket.
What if I accidentally drive off a cliff? I thought morbidly. That would make me the rock equivalent of Buddy Holly's pilot. Not something I've ever aspired to.
We arrived at the "airport" where her husband was waiting for her. He walked towards Sarah, veered with a startled look towards my wife and gave HER a big hug. Turns out they'd gone to high school together.
And there you go. Nothing dramatic. Not even any photographic proof to my friends who have cried "bullshit." But it's my favourite brush-with-fame story, made all the more wonderful for just how completely normal it all seemed.
too cool! totally! |
|
daliebe (Victoria, B.C.) | | Posted: Mar 28, 2007 - 11:44 | |
Well, I've been dying to share my Sarah story somewhere. RP is as good a place as any.
My wife and I were flying to Tofino, B.C. for a winter holiday. The airport (really just a little strip of pavement surrounded by forest) was fogged in and our pilot told us we had to land on the other side of the mountain range.
Sarah's flight had also been diverted; she was coming home after performing a tsunami relief concert in Calgary. She looked totally bagged, and had her young daughter with her. She spoke on her cell, telling her husband "I'll just rent a car and get there in a couple hours."
"Hi, I'm David," I said to her. "My name's Sarah," she answered. Well, duh.
I asked if we could share a vehicle with her and she was glad to. It meant she could sit in the back and tend to her daughter who got car sick on the twisty road. Just your everyday pop star with puke on her jacket.
What if I accidentally drive off a cliff? I thought morbidly. That would make me the rock equivalent of Buddy Holly's pilot. Not something I've ever aspired to.
We arrived at the "airport" where her husband was waiting for her. He walked towards Sarah, veered with a startled look towards my wife and gave HER a big hug. Turns out they'd gone to high school together.
And there you go. Nothing dramatic. Not even any photographic proof to my friends who have cried "bullshit." But it's my favourite brush-with-fame story, made all the more wonderful for just how completely normal it all seemed.
|
|
Geecheeboy (under a crescent moon and palmetto tree) | | Posted: Mar 13, 2006 - 17:55 | |
rixtar99 wrote:Some of you think that if you cover a Beatle song you should go to jail. Sarah makes it her own and does a good job.
Yeah for one thing she capoes up and changes the key a little. Nice clean pickin too. Better than MY version for sure. |
|
sandpebble (near Paradise) | | Posted: Dec 30, 2005 - 12:46 | |
No No No No No Honey,  Don't do that. It's bad Manners and it doesnt sound so good.
I don't hear anything original brought to the table here at all.
My kindest of compliments to the composer. |
|
denizenusa
| | Posted: Dec 30, 2005 - 12:42 | |
|
iMacomania (Bavaria - Germany) | | Posted: Dec 30, 2005 - 12:42 | |
She should sing a duet with Paul. |
|
Essbee (Big Bend Region, Texas) | | Posted: Dec 30, 2005 - 12:41 | |
This is one of the few if not the only tolerable cuts on the I Am Sam CD. Very nice. Most Beatles covers are forced and pointless.
|
|
rixtar99 (The O.C.) | | Posted: Dec 01, 2005 - 11:09 | |
Some of you think that if you cover a Beatle song you should go to jail. Sarah makes it her own and does a good job.
|
|
dango
| | Posted: Dec 01, 2005 - 10:47 | |
|
BKardon (Boulder, CO) | | Posted: Nov 16, 2005 - 19:27 | |
Hob wrote:Lots of people here saying "What has she added".
Umm... her voice?
Would she mind taking it back? |
|
Akaiila (London, UK) | | Posted: Oct 18, 2005 - 13:17 | |
Love Sarah, but this one just wasn't really going anywhere for me. A bit like my cooking - all the right ingredients, but didn't quite live up to expectations!
|
|
Birchleaf
| | Posted: Oct 03, 2005 - 20:42 | |
Not bad. Prefer the original.
I agree. But all the same, it's better than nothing. I have the original if I want to hear it, anyway. |
|
redbird (Berkeley, CA) | | Posted: Aug 20, 2005 - 09:58 | |
chasech5 wrote:Not bad. Prefer the original.
My feelings exactly. |
|
jbtidwell (Atlanta, GA) | | Posted: Aug 05, 2005 - 13:03 | |
atticus wrote:Didn't see the movie. Don't really want to watch Sean Penn in this role. Can understand now why she even attempted the cover, if it was for a movie sound track.
But, unfortunately, didn't want to hear someone else, no matter how beautiful her voice, touch something so perfect as McCartney's "Blackbird." Tried to listen to it with an open-mind, but in the end, felt disappointed. Saddened.
It's a bit like Feliciano covering The Doors gem, Light My Fire, isn't it.
"What would possess an artist to cover a Beatles song? Its an important question to ponder while listening to this album. The Sean Penn Oscar-bait movie couldnt get access to original Beatles songs, so they went to V2 records and assembled a quickie lineup of seventeen covers from todays top alterna-acts. Its no surprise that the album is a mixed bag to say the least."
(click here)
Even so, I LOVE Sarah McLachlan and I LOVE her version of this song :D |
|
mxdcec
| | Posted: Aug 05, 2005 - 13:02 | |
Kinda like listening to William Shatner sing In da Gadda da Vida.
|
|
cbonai (Vermont) | | Posted: Jun 22, 2005 - 07:13 | |
Great song+great singer=great remake, though original still rules still is the best!
|
|