slartibart_O (N29°57'-W97°34') | | Posted: Nov 07, 2007 - 10:26 | |
suddenchad wrote:
Your comments are sincere and I am not going to criticize what you are saying, except for your final sentence. I find the juxtaposition irritating. Amazing Grace is a beautiful song on its own. House of the Rising Sun is an incredible song. You have two timeless songs in their own right, each demanding their own treatment. Why muddy the waters? When this comes on, I'd rather hear either or, not a "mash-up." Individually, I'm sure the Blind Boys could do both spectacularly.
Ehh. I'm w/ CC on this one. Not just a bit of irony here mixing a redemption spiritual with a song about hoplessness in a whorehouse - the two work together rather well musically to make a third entity. Nice. |
|
gwynhefar
| | Posted: Nov 07, 2007 - 10:22 | |
I liked it, but I couldn't help singing House of the Rising Sun under my breath the whole time. It'd be interesting to hear the two songs done as a round.
|
|
nagsheadlocal (North Carolina, the new New Jersey) | | Posted: Nov 07, 2007 - 10:21 | |
The Blind Boys have been around forever. My grandparents took me to see them in the late 50s. Gospel and bluegrass was about the only music heard live in that rural area. Hearing this style come back into the public arena makes me happy.
|
|
kindermanltd
| | Posted: Nov 07, 2007 - 10:18 | |
House of the Rising Grace? I guess I still like it either way though.
|
|
UltraNurd (Boston, MA) | | Posted: Nov 07, 2007 - 10:17 | |
I know at least three "praise style" (that is, acoustic guitar plus vocals, geared towards a youth camp worship service) of Amazing Grace, all of which stand on their own merits.
This is another great reimagining.
|
|
ziggytrix (Dallas, TX) | | Posted: Sep 05, 2007 - 13:42 | |
suddenchad wrote:I find the juxtaposition irritating. Amazing Grace is a beautiful song on its own. House of the Rising Sun is an incredible song. You have two timeless songs in their own right, each demanding their own treatment. Why muddy the waters?
It seems obvious to me that they were trying, quite successfully in my opinion, to push a spiritual hymn into a whole other realm. |
|
Clif (Saint Charles, IL) | | Posted: Sep 05, 2007 - 13:36 | |
I saw the Blind Boys of Alabama do this song live. The entire concert was amazing and this song was maybe the best.
This song is good here on Radio Paradise but it is much better live. At Least it was the one time I saw them.
|
|
walkerpub (Windsor, Ontario, Canada) | | Posted: Sep 05, 2007 - 13:34 | |
This one is spectacular- especially live- The Blind Boys only sing "religious" songs- so House of the Riing Sun would be out of the question...
|
|
jpfueler (South o' Ft Worth) | | Posted: Jul 04, 2007 - 15:12 | |
suddenchad wrote:
Your comments are sincere and I am not going to criticize what you are saying, except for your final sentence. I find the juxtaposition irritating. Amazing Grace is a beautiful song on its own. House of the Rising Sun is an incredible song. You have two timeless songs in their own right, each demanding their own treatment. Why muddy the waters? When this comes on, I'd rather hear either or, not a "mash-up." Individually, I'm sure the Blind Boys could do both spectacularly. I have to agree with CC on this. I like the juxtaposition. |
|
Alifreckles50 (Frederick, MD) | | Posted: Jun 03, 2007 - 07:13 | |
thank you for this. I was feeling extremely guilty at blowing off church....but I'm singing this and, in my heart, I'm there. God bless
|
|
madaxeman (Scottish west coast) | | Posted: Apr 01, 2007 - 07:01 | |
I am PISSED OFF at missing this.I went to make tea and came back to find I'd missed it.Spookily,I had been reading about Gospel/religious music at the time and this very version of this song hed just been mentioned.
A Scottish tune BTW.
|
|
suddenchad
| | Posted: Mar 16, 2007 - 17:21 | |
cc_rider wrote:I am stunned by the negative comments regarding this song. 'Amazing Grace' was written by a slavetrader who saw the error of his ways. Religion does not necessarily enter into it; slavery is (still) a moral abomination regardless of religious affiliation.
I feel the deepest sadness for anyone who's been abused in the name of 'religion'; people who twist holy teachings (of all sorts) for their personal perversions occupy a special sort of hell. And in fairness, a song can conjur negative feelings even though the song itself is positive. Amazing Grace is a song of redemption, of realizing the fundamental immorality of your actions.
House of the Rising Sun, on the other hand, is a song of hopelessness, of utter despair. It's exact references are the subject of some debate, but the lyrics indicate being at the 'end of the line'.
The juxtaposition is spectacular, and the Blind Boys sing it with power and grace.
c.
Your comments are sincere and I am not going to criticize what you are saying, except for your final sentence. I find the juxtaposition irritating. Amazing Grace is a beautiful song on its own. House of the Rising Sun is an incredible song. You have two timeless songs in their own right, each demanding their own treatment. Why muddy the waters? When this comes on, I'd rather hear either or, not a "mash-up." Individually, I'm sure the Blind Boys could do both spectacularly. |
|
cc_rider (Austin Texas. Y'all.) | | Posted: Feb 13, 2007 - 10:16 | |
I am stunned by the negative comments regarding this song. 'Amazing Grace' was written by a slavetrader who saw the error of his ways. Religion does not necessarily enter into it; slavery is (still) a moral abomination regardless of religious affiliation.
I feel the deepest sadness for anyone who's been abused in the name of 'religion'; people who twist holy teachings (of all sorts) for their personal perversions occupy a special sort of hell. And in fairness, a song can conjur negative feelings even though the song itself is positive. Amazing Grace is a song of redemption, of realizing the fundamental immorality of your actions.
House of the Rising Sun, on the other hand, is a song of hopelessness, of utter despair. It's exact references are the subject of some debate, but the lyrics indicate being at the 'end of the line'.
The juxtaposition is spectacular, and the Blind Boys sing it with power and grace.
c.
|
|
ElSupreme (ATL) | | Posted: Feb 13, 2007 - 10:08 | |
ZarSU wrote:
Ever hear "Stairway to Gilligan"? Stairway to Heaven, with the Gilligan lyrics, great ice breaker at any party. It was done by "Little Roger and the Goosebumps", do a Google and you will will get some low quality versions to listen to.
Zar
Very worth while. Whoever is singing can't quite hit the notes robert plant can, but definately worth a listen. |
|
ElSupreme (ATL) | | Posted: Feb 13, 2007 - 10:07 | |
jksteacher wrote:Holy smokes....
God is alive and well. And making music, it would seem. So much for agnosticism.
Who needs agnosticism. I am an Atheist, nothing for me to wonder about. |
|
celadonstone (Southeast of the USA) | | Posted: Feb 13, 2007 - 10:03 | |
Qliphah wrote:
Ooooh wow thought for a second there "land of the rising sun" was set to amazing grace, but then I thought about it... Should have played Rolling Stones tho. Not that I have anything against religious music.
This is a really cool combination of melody and song, gives a lovely Gulf coast feel it might not otherwise have.
I guess HOTRS was done by the Stones, but a version that gets typical airplay is by the Animals. The lead singer says New Or-le-ans, not 'Nawlins like a native would. :-) (tangent=love dialects!!!)
A friend in Savannah does a smokin' version of HOTRS too. If you're in those parts, see Brett the Hitman at Savannah Blues.... |
|
mikerobinson
| | Posted: Feb 13, 2007 - 10:03 | |
haha amazing grace to the music of the house of the rising sun. Awesome.
|
|
(former member) (Retirement Capital of the World) | | Posted: Feb 13, 2007 - 10:01 | |
This is THE song that led me to RP a few months back. I will be forever grateful to the Blind Boys for that.
|
|
dionysius (The People's Republic of Austin) | | Posted: Feb 13, 2007 - 09:59 | |
There is no god, no heaven, no salvation, no life after death. But this makes me want to pray. |
|
ElSupreme (ATL) | | Posted: Feb 13, 2007 - 09:59 | |
Man I really don't like this song, but this version sounds pretty damn good.
|
|
slowhand (South!!!!!!!!!!) | | Posted: Dec 31, 2006 - 14:16 | |
|
bokey
| | Posted: Dec 31, 2006 - 14:15 | |
I only gave it a 9 but I'm kind of a jerk.
|
|
mandolin
| | Posted: Dec 31, 2006 - 14:15 | |
...hearing this song cemented my affection for radio paradise, when i first stumbled upon the station last year...
|
|
thewaxtadpole
| | Posted: Dec 02, 2006 - 11:47 | |
If I could, I'd rate it 10 again.
|
|
curtkare (Chicago, America) | | Posted: Nov 19, 2006 - 19:38 | |
ZarSU wrote:Anyone who is a true music lover will say this classic was done with the utmost class. The people who made the racist comments are listening to the wrong channel, Radio Paradise is for TRUE music lovers that listen to the music, not the color/religion/ethnic backgrounds of the artists that make them.
Zar
Look up a definition of IRONY, then read those "racist comments" again. |
|
jksteacher (Atlanta) | | Posted: Nov 19, 2006 - 19:37 | |
Holy smokes....
God is alive and well. And making music, it would seem. So much for agnosticism.
|
|
ZarSU (RI aka the arm pit of New England) | | Posted: Nov 03, 2006 - 06:31 | |
mojoman wrote:
You can, believe it or not, sing the lyrics to the tune of "Gilligan's Island," too. Go figure.
Ever hear "Stairway to Gilligan"? Stairway to Heaven, with the Gilligan lyrics, great ice breaker at any party. It was done by "Little Roger and the Goosebumps", do a Google and you will will get some low quality versions to listen to.
Zar |
|
ZarSU (RI aka the arm pit of New England) | | Posted: Nov 03, 2006 - 06:19 | |
Anyone who is a true music lover will say this classic was done with the utmost class. The people who made the racist comments are listening to the wrong channel, Radio Paradise is for TRUE music lovers that listen to the music, not the color/religion/ethnic backgrounds of the artists that make them.
Zar
|
|
Qliphah (In your castle slaying your vassals) | | Posted: Nov 03, 2006 - 06:15 | |
kevin36 wrote:
It's the lyrics to Amazing Grace set to the melody of House of the Rising Sun.
Ooooh wow thought for a second there "land of the rising sun" was set to amazing grace, but then I thought about it... Should have played Rolling Stones tho. Not that I have anything against religious music. |
|
strick (Syracuse- your sympathy accepted...) | | Posted: Nov 03, 2006 - 06:14 | |
portlad wrote:
Bleh.
Ditto. |
|