| Cynaera wrote: I agree that the pauses between phrases are difficult - but I think it's an effective way of making the listener actually stop and LISTEN to the words (as usual, very vivid imagery, and I bet Stephen King could write a hell of a story around this song.) When a song flows along effortlessly, sometimes one has a tendency to forget to absorb other aspects of the song, such as the instruments, the lyrics, the cadence... This song uses an unorthodox method to pull focus back to the song. Whether you love it or hate it, I feel one must at least respect the approach and the intention. Me? I kinda like it. It reminds me of when I was learning to ice-skate. Three steps, a little coast, and a hard landing. Get up, take three more shaky steps, coast a little further, land again... By the end, I truly appreciated ice-skating to the point where I never wanted to do it again. Miss you so much, Cynaera... love this song... |
| hippiechick wrote: I am so used to the Joan Osborne version, I think I like hers better, but it's a great song. thanks for mentioning this--I wanted to buy her version but couldn't remember her name. Bob is doing a Tom Waits imitation here. Hard to understand him with the growl and choppy bitten-off delivery. |
| ZiegZeon wrote: This is one of the few Dylan songs that I actually enjoy. The atmosphere set up by the back ground make sound great. Like out in a swamp with the crickets. This. Dylan drives me crazy most of the time but this is actually rather nice. |
| hippiechick wrote: I am so used to the Joan Osborne version, I think I like hers better, but it's a great song. Amen sister! |
| I am so used to the Joan Osborne version, I think I like hers better, but it's a great song. |
XstarFeb 15, 2012 - 02:14 | Not today! WTH? 7  6 Way too staccato! |
| This is one of the few Dylan songs that I actually enjoy. The atmosphere set up by the back ground make sound great. Like out in a swamp with the crickets. |
mrgusOct 11, 2011 - 07:11 | I prefer Rolf Harris's "The Big Black Hat". |
| Maggle_Bish wrote: And another one to add to the list - I know it's wrong but I just like her cover better. Ha! I was just thinking the same thing myselg |
| alanthecowboy wrote: Here's a fellow heretic, agreeing wholeheartedly with you. Joan's was the first version I heard, but even if that wasn't the case, it works way better for me. And another one to add to the list - I know it's wrong but I just like her cover better. |
| I agree that the pauses between phrases are difficult - but I think it's an effective way of making the listener actually stop and LISTEN to the words (as usual, very vivid imagery, and I bet Stephen King could write a hell of a story around this song.) When a song flows along effortlessly, sometimes one has a tendency to forget to absorb other aspects of the song, such as the instruments, the lyrics, the cadence... This song uses an unorthodox method to pull focus back to the song. Whether you love it or hate it, I feel one must at least respect the approach and the intention. Me? I kinda like it. It reminds me of when I was learning to ice-skate. Three steps, a little coast, and a hard landing. Get up, take three more shaky steps, coast a little further, land again... By the end, I truly appreciated ice-skating to the point where I never wanted to do it again. |
| With ya... rabbi_phil wrote: Oh Mercy is right! I'm one of Dylans' biggest fans but this just brutal. |
| SlinkyJ wrote: I know this is heresy, but I like Joan Osborne's cover better. Here's a fellow heretic, agreeing wholeheartedly with you. Joan's was the first version I heard, but even if that wasn't the case, it works way better for me. |
| Baby_M wrote: What's up . . . with the abrupt . . . pauses in the middle . . . of each line. Is this Bob . . . Dylan or . . . Paul Harvey, . . . the "Prince . . . of Pause"? Good day! |
| Oh Mercy is right! I'm one of Dylans' biggest fans but this just brutal. |
drewsApr 05, 2011 - 05:58 | Solitary men in long black coats, some are bad guys and some are good guys |
| Bob Dylan channels Cake. |
| Dear god this is awful. |
| This is as boring as a poem in Iambic Pentameter. |
| What's up . . . with the abrupt . . . pauses in the middle . . . of each line. Is this Bob . . . Dylan or . . . Paul Harvey, . . . the "Prince . . . of Pause"? Good day! |