| now playing | menu | music library |
Bonnie Raitt
Silver Lining Silver Lining (2002) Buy CD Buy MP3 |
| 46 comments: | lyrics: | add your comment |
PJay Mar 18, 2005 - 04:01 | I rather like Bonnie Raitt, but what a strange thing to do. Make a watered down cover of an excellent original song. :-k |
Pyro Mar 03, 2005 - 10:28 | radiomao wrote: And you need to clear your palette of this newer, often overproduced Bonnie...her incomparable artistry is much easier to "taste" in her earlier work...such as "I Feel The Same" a Chris Smither (I think) cover on Takin' My Time. You're right, early Bonnie has a more funky, less produced feel. Her first 4-5 albums were phenomenal. I LOVE her, and happen to like both early and newer stuff. Still think "Nick of Time" is an INCREDIBLE CD. |
radiomao Mar 03, 2005 - 10:13 | Avatard wrote: You need to clear your palette of the of the other Played to Death David Gray songs and hear his version of this. Far, far better than this. And you need to clear your palette of this newer, often overproduced Bonnie...her incomparable artistry is much easier to "taste" in her earlier work...such as "I Feel The Same" a Chris Smither (I think) cover on Takin' My Time. |
DD Avatard Mar 03, 2005 - 10:05 | Dave_Mack wrote: I think this is beautiful. It really reminds me of K.D. Lang, actually, both in the arrangement and the vocal style. Haven't heard the David Gray version. The only songs I've heard of his have been played to death by KFrOG, so I'm not that excited by him. My loss, I suppose.
You need to clear your palette of the of the other Played to Death David Gray songs and hear his version of this. Far, far better than this. |
psycholynx Mar 03, 2005 - 10:04 | Bonnie rocks the slide like no other. Too bad it is barely heard here. :( |
Dave_Mack Feb 16, 2005 - 16:05 | I think this is beautiful. It really reminds me of K.D. Lang, actually, both in the arrangement and the vocal style. Haven't heard the David Gray version. The only songs I've heard of his have been played to death by KFrOG, so I'm not that excited by him. My loss, I suppose. |
trekhead Jan 18, 2005 - 04:35 | I thought of 'HOLLY HOLY(?)' by ND in the first notes. |
Trustocity Jan 03, 2005 - 11:18 | Shaken_Bake wrote: I think Bonnie's version of this song is superior to David Gray's... she puts more emotion into it and the production is superb. And I'm not usually a fan of covers, especially when the original came out not long before. Great song, great rendition.
Bonnie may be more technically expressive in her singing, but there's NO way she's more emotive than David. His songs work exactly because he don't drown them in so-called superb production. No surprise, I agree with those who said they preferred the original. Personally, I don't think much of Bonnie's skills to begin with. That's a matter of taste; of course I know she's a wonderful musician and singer, but I don't like listening to her. |
coding_to_music Jan 03, 2005 - 11:12 | David Gray's version is wonderfully excellent, but the sonic quality and expressivness of this version is equally good, IMHO... |
Mugro Jan 03, 2005 - 11:09 | gntlemanartist wrote: I prefer David Grey's version.
Me too! More David Gray! |
trekhead Nov 05, 2004 - 08:12 | Bonnie Raitt and X-Men's Rogue...separated at birth?
Think about it! |
gntlemanartist Nov 05, 2004 - 08:05 | I prefer David Grey's version. |
pcolajoe Sep 07, 2004 - 08:29 | superfido wrote: Hmm. Shows you what I know. I thought aliens had abducted her or something somewhere around 1989.
Or she had just simply vanished with the dying moments of that decade. :???: Sadly, I have to agree. Awsome woman, great singer, undeniable feelings, but it just hasn't been the same for a long while. I'll always hang on to the great stuff! |
rKokon Sep 07, 2004 - 08:29 | I have a higher opinion of the merits of Bonnie Raitt's voice than Clarinetta does. Now when do you play some Bette Midler, whom I haven't heard in so long? |
Shaken_Bake Jun 15, 2004 - 10:50 | I think Bonnie's version of this song is superior to David Gray's... she puts more emotion into it and the production is superb. And I'm not usually a fan of covers, especially when the original came out not long before. Great song, great rendition. |
Leslie May 19, 2004 - 23:34 | Xenochronicity wrote: I had a chance to meet her about '85. She came to a picnic after the show, and we washed dishes together. This woman is as close to perfect as an artist gets, horribly under rated, and a damn nice girl! To those who think she sux; go to a Brittney concert, buy a poster, whack off and quit hanging out here where the real artsists are! Cool story! I have always wanted to meet her to tell her how much her music means to me (no gushing I would be cool about it). Alas, no luck. I'm glad you got to meet her and your assessemnt of her does not surprise me in the least. |
dadofsammy May 06, 2004 - 19:40 | Never heard this one before....I'm part of the first wave of Bonnie fans....saw her first in 1978. Haven't really kept current, so every time I hear a more recent on RP, it's like a little gift under the tree.
This one has a style and even melody similar to some tracks on KD Lang's "Ingenue". A very nice tune indeed, Mr. Gray. |
Xenochronicity Mar 29, 2004 - 09:47 | Leslie wrote: Probably Brittany Spears Bonnie's voice just gets better and sexier with age. I first saw her in 1976 at the Greek Theater on the UC Berkeley campus. I had a chance to meet her about '85. She came to a picnic after the show, and we washed dishes together. This woman is as close to perfect as an artist gets, horribly under rated, and a damn nice girl! To those who think she sux; go to a Brittney concert, buy a poster, whack off and quit hanging out here where the real artsists are! |
audiozeb Apr 24, 2003 - 13:09 | Originally Posted by clarinetta:
Bonnie Raitt has a terrible voice just like Bette Midler and the songs by both of these women are not worth listening to at all. But Freur "Doot Doot" is "Godlike"? OK, whatEVER Anyway this was OK, but I truly LOVE the David Gray version. Bonnie gets a 5 for this one. Edited By audiozeb at 1:10 pm on 4/24/2003 |
missjanuary Apr 14, 2003 - 08:27 | Originally Posted by robinesque:
If architecture is frozen music, then Bonnie Raitt's voice is melted sculpture - as fluid as windblown silk, and as solid as polished marble. (like, Bonnie rocks) But the music is overblown socks and leaden dullness. Did you know that 'bonnie raitt' is an anagram of 'granny nattering'. :p |
