| now playing | menu | music library |
Sarah McLachlan
Dear God Rarities, B-Sides, And Other Stuff (1996) |
| 33 comments: | lyrics: | add your comment |
Krispian Sep 11, 2006 - 01:07 | bakedjake wrote: blasphemy. where the hell is XTC when you need them?
Certainly not here. |
winter Jul 06, 2005 - 23:43 | Machiavelli wrote: Credit definitely goes to XTC for a good song, and Andy Partridge for great lyrics, but Sarah's voice does a powerful job of conveying the emotion, especially the anger - I like the original, but I love the cover.
Hear, hear! |
jovino Nov 04, 2003 - 15:55 | Dear God, don't let Sarah cover this song! If God was one of us, he'd tell her to shut up!
UGH! |
misterlee Nov 04, 2003 - 15:54 | qbee wrote: I love this song, and love Sarah, but it mostly makes me think "wow, I'd sure love to hear XTC!" or perhaps some Dukes of Stratosphere?
Right On!!! |
qbee Oct 04, 2003 - 22:08 | I love this song, and love Sarah, but it mostly makes me think "wow, I'd sure love to hear XTC!" or perhaps some Dukes of Stratosphere? |
Machiavelli Sep 24, 2003 - 16:47 | Credit definitely goes to XTC for a good song, and Andy Partridge for great lyrics, but Sarah's voice does a powerful job of conveying the emotion, especially the anger - I like the original, but I love the cover. |
catmanning Sep 04, 2003 - 18:25 | i like sarah.
but xtc just had this down. loved the kids voice in the original. i had all of the xtc tapes. still favor them. |
Shimmer Aug 14, 2003 - 23:03 | She sucked all the anger out of an angry song! What's left is pretty, but empty. |
coldatlantic Jul 25, 2003 - 13:03 | I love Sarah's voice, but I find her music just dilutes good ideas. It drowns them in a soup of breathy padded background vocals.. This would be cool to hear live as an homage to the original, but as a recording it's less quirky and less endearing. |
southend Jul 25, 2003 - 13:00 | What? What? What?
I just can't relate to this. "I don't need a reduction in the price of beer" That's devil talk! |
marci28 Jul 15, 2003 - 08:25 | nice cover. |
silverpoet Jul 15, 2003 - 08:19 | don't care what y'all say... Sarah rocks
|
bakedjake Jul 15, 2003 - 08:17 | blasphemy. where the hell is XTC when you need them? |
catsoup Jun 04, 2003 - 13:09 | I'm not quite sure what emotion she's trying to convey. Overall, a muddled half-attempt at a cover.
We need a "Straight to the dustbin!" rating. |
pigglywiggly Jun 04, 2003 - 13:09 | Yep, she trying way too hard with this.
Blech. :( |
dignan2 Jun 04, 2003 - 13:09 | Sorry, Sarah. XTC's is the better version.
|
AliGator Jun 04, 2003 - 13:07 | I think I prefer the original. Gotta love the guitar as done by XTC. |
kerneld Jun 04, 2003 - 13:07 | I like Sarah McLachlan, but I don't like this song very much. |
tulfan Jun 04, 2003 - 13:06 | Originally Posted by Eulogy:
Your comments nailed it for me. This is way to feigned for inclusion in this format... Theres just too much faux emotion piled on top of what was orignially a cold declaration of atheism. |
Time37 May 15, 2003 - 04:25 | I am a sucker for cover songs, but the case is very rare in which a cover surpasses the original (Vedder doing Masters of War!!!). However, I think I like Sarah's version better than the XTC original.
|
