| I agree with "dig", the original is excellent. |
| Just relax everyone. The Cowboy Junkies did a fine job but they were fortunate to have such a great song to work with. As far as definative version - track one, Rock 'n Roll Animal. |
| merkin_muffley wrote: Only gave this 4 as the live version is a 10. Twice as good and more, if that makes any sense. |
| Ahh! This is just what the doctor ordered! Great classic tune! For those of you who don't understand why I rate this a 9 see below: |
| The phrase "velvet underground" refers to Marquis de Sade's description of the anus... I would guess the band giggled all the time about it... this song rocks... love it... |
| You know how some songs can trigger a vivid memory? This song does that for me. I can picture exactly where I was and who I was with the first time I heard this song. I don't know the date exactly, but it was >40 yrs ago, the album was rather new, and I was an early teen. At that age of course I thought I knew everything; I think this song imprinted the memory because it was so different from what I *had* thought was "good music". Eye opening and transformative, it'll always be a 10 in my book. |
| stellar. ..just as it is. perfect, like the wildflowers in light reflected off broken glass of a city street. it's not smooth and shouldn't be cause it's rock an roll |
| PA1749 wrote: Wow, compared to the Cowboy Junkies, this sucks. Maybe to you it does. |
| LOVE the Velvet Underground...this hit me in the belly! Visceral & awesome, how pure their rock n' roll. |
| Only gave this 4 as the live version is a 10. Twice as good and more, if that makes any sense. |
| so awesome to hear VU on RP it hardly ever happens. thanks bill! |
| Love live version on Rock n Roll Animal - Live album. Leaves CJ in the dirt. |
| |
| romeotuma wrote: Love this song, but this is one of the rare cases where I love a cover even more— the Cowboy Junkies make this song soooo smooth and sexy... Agreed... |
| Hey rotten, Uh....do you like guitar in r n r songs? Uh...maybe you want to listen to Reed playing it. Some of the best. |
| PA1749 wrote: Wow, compared to the Cowboy Junkies, this sucks. Mott the Hoople do the best version of this song. |
| I've made sweet love to the CJ's version on many an occasion, so it holds a special place in my heart. But the VU version is infinitely more seminal (forgive the pun). |
| There are so many great songs on this album, Head Held High, Train Round the Bend, Who Loves the Sun, New Age, Rock & Roll, Lonesome Cowboy Bill. |
| A little sick of it; but it's a great song a a great album. |
| Wow, compared to the Cowboy Junkies, this sucks. |