Originally Posted by anamacha:
anyone wanna tell me why this song sounds like a lot of the same 'progressive rock' out there like Soundgarden, Alice in Chain, etc?

Originally Posted by lbrc:

perhaps the dixie chicks should have taken your advice before they ran their mouth.

Originally Posted by ladybinnath:
Dave Matthews never fails to make me reach for the mute button.

Originally Posted by chieromancer:
Can't help it, but every time I hear The Catster, I think of Moslems and when I think of Moslems, I think of terrorists, which ruins the song for me. I also think of his comments following the Salman Rushdie death threats. I was totally into Cat Stevens in H.S., too. (What a hunk! What a loss!)

Originally Posted by yeastiebeastie:


Any of three dozen bands from Seattle or Portland could have blown the Pumpkykins off the stage on any given night. And most of those bands - unlike the Whinykins - could accurately be described as "alterhnative".

I'm sure the same could have been said of ANY city with a decent music scene. Christ, the Pumpkins suck...

Originally Posted by Heathen:
What the hell is this crap.

DMB are VERY overrated....

Kill me now... please....

Originally Posted by lily34:



you're right, but this particular track is taken from the much more recent STRIPPED, if you look above.
not one of their better live tunes, at least not recently.

Originally Posted by corneliusworm:
I don't need to hear any more Stevie Wonder.

Originally Posted by ScottFromWyoming:


Now Beck decided to write some actual songs that might show he has actual talent (some of us didn't need to have that pointed out) and isn't just a studio freak

Originally Posted by mread:
Intolerable, as is most of PF's stuff, especially THE WALL. It's not eclectic, and not intelligent.

Originally Posted by mysiren:
Please stop playing crappy jazz.

Originally Posted by cleveland:
There is no comparison whatsoever between the Dead and their improvisional roots based jams and DMB's whiney, pre-packaged, produced-to-sell records type stuff.

Originally Posted by dmax:


I'm with you. This period of music really never ever clicked with me. This means about as much to me as that band ABC or Duran Duran.

Strictly posers, and not musicians for the sake of music. :
(

Originally Posted by redshifted:


I think the 'we' in your comment should be changed to 'I'. there, that sounds better.

Originally Posted by Leslie:

Me too! The Dead's music has enabled me to get through some really rough times in my life. Whenever I feel bad I listen to the Dead and I immediately feel much better.

Originally Posted by RonH:
Who's the 2 rateing FAG!

Originally Posted by mlsully7:
I don't understand why so many people just pass this song off as "rap crap." Sure he's "rapping," but this isn't "rap music." He's not sitting there talking about bullets or bitches or bling bling, he's talking about social problems. Those (ignorant) people who just dismiss this as "rap crap" obviously don't know what they're talking about and don't know a damn thing about good hip hop and the talent it involves. (other great hip hop bands include Jurassic 5, De La Soul, Dilated Peoples, and The Roots (who play all their own instruments and write all their own music).

Originally Posted by eric:
These guys are so overated. Fortunately they're quickly slipping into obscurity.

Originally Posted by ahadesign:
I saw Badly Drawn Boy live a few months ago. It was, bar none, the worst show I ever saw. It was a massive ego trip for that bozo and nothing more. First of all, he started the show by actually spitting on the audience! :???:


Funny, in nyc they played an incredible show, and started it by playing a hysterical short film about jon bon jovi's pool boy....it must have had something to do with the venue or something...or maybe he just likes nyc!

Originally Posted by seawolf:
this was garbage when it was still fresh, now
it is just stale garbage.

Originally Posted by splacknuck:
Less of this please -- RP is not an old people's radio

Originally Posted by BC_Night_Heron:
I'm trying to keep an open mind, but Wilco comes across as just another nondescript midtempo alt oriented country group that really does not stand out. What am I missing?

Originally Posted by john:

Originally Posted by oldman2112:
Where's the music? Seems blocked again?

Originally Posted by KevDog:
I pull up the comments on this one and am just stunned to see the negative remarks. Joni is terrific, and so is this song.

Originally Posted by zaknafein:
Wasn't essentially the entire album done months ago, they just had to find a new label to publish it?

I'm glad they did, absolutely superb.

Originally Posted by KevDog:
Alright, I guess I am officially too old. But, in my honest (and experienced) opinion, this is absolute crap that any moron with a keyboard and a tape recorder could do (but said moron should be strongly discouraged). I don't see any talent in Radiohead. Sign me old fogey.