[ ]      [ ]   [ ]
Log in above to post your comment
Misterfixit
(Nashville)
Posted: Sep 02, 2009 - 11:23
 

 Wasted wrote:
Whether the lyrics were originally written from a woman's perspective or not, it still comes off as a story about a guy and his boyfriend...  and I like it that way.
 
If it is good music it's good.  If it grating with a poor voice, then it is not good music.
This track stinks.



pugifat
Posted: Sep 02, 2009 - 11:20
 

the vocals are so over-wrought ...err over-rot

fredriley
(Nottingham, UK)
Posted: Sep 02, 2009 - 11:17
 

If the song was as good as the band name this would be worth a 7, but sadly the voice not only grates but is irritatingly twee, as are the lyrics. Indeed, it sounds as tedious as James Blunt. 2 from the Nottingham jury.

lily34
(lexvegas)
Posted: Jul 01, 2009 - 04:55
 

not their best. and not a cover. no idea where people are getting that. but, the rest of the cd is awesome. huffamoose is so much fun live, too. give them a chance even if you don't dig this tune specifically.

Pyro
Posted: May 30, 2009 - 09:45
 

7 ==> 6

RadioDoc
(Chicagoland)
Posted: Feb 24, 2009 - 16:03
 

 manbirdexperiment wrote:

Just had to give this a bump. I'm reeling with nausea. 
 
Thank you for nothing.  Didn't Bill delete that damn thing yet?  You've posted it to at least 150 threads. {#Rolleyes}

Manbird
(Santa Rosa, CA)
Posted: Feb 24, 2009 - 16:01
 

 manbirdexperiment wrote:
 
Just had to give this a bump. I'm reeling with nausea. 

ragshagbill
Posted: Feb 24, 2009 - 16:01
 

Ick.
When it started I thought it might be bad enough to be Jack Johnson.
But it's not quite that bad.  But close.
 

Sonomacathouse
(Sonoma, CA)
Posted: Feb 24, 2009 - 16:00
 

 trekhead wrote:
Anyone getting

"JANE'S GETTING SERIOUS"
by John Astley?
 

I love that song.  Whatever happened to John Astley?
OMG - I just had a quick (and thankfully fleeting) memory - Rick Astley.  Whatever happened to him?

CanyonMan
Posted: Dec 20, 2008 - 22:49
 

 scruzer wrote:

For you it's silly — for me it's refreshing to hear a man sing of his relationship with another man.

Have some respect for the rest of us.

 
I do.  And I would also find it interesting and refreshing to hear good, credible lyrics about two men or two women in love.  I was just echoing the observation, made by several others, that if you listen carefully to the lyrics, it's extremely unlikely that they were written to mean that.

Don't be so quick to feel disrespected.


trekhead
(Arkham, G.C.)
Posted: Oct 21, 2008 - 09:16
 

Anyone getting

"JANE'S GETTING SERIOUS"
by John Astley?



ch83575
Posted: Oct 21, 2008 - 08:55
 

 mandolin wrote:
...i don't have any problem at all with performers covering songs from the opposing gender's perspective, but i think it's a bit silly to interpret this as a gay man's perspective - the 'flower girl' references just comes across flamingly comical that way...

 
I couldn't agree more.  So... who wrote it?  I gave it a few tries via google, but no luck.  The funny thing is that I am fairly sure that I have heard the original song.  Even before getting to the flower girl part (sorry all, it is a little silly) I thought it was a cover of a song that I was familiar with.  I would love to find the original now.

Edit:  AllMusic has the composer as Craig Elkins of Huffamoose.  ???


mandolin
(...drifting...)
Posted: Oct 21, 2008 - 08:50
 

...i don't have any problem at all with performers covering songs from the opposing gender's perspective, but i think it's a bit silly to interpret this as a gay man's perspective - the 'flower girl' references just comes across flamingly comical that way...


vandal
(arriving somewhere, but not here. . .)
Posted: Oct 21, 2008 - 08:49
 


Meh; sounds like these guys were huffing moose fumes. . .


Kittee
(NC- Dreaming of the Mountains)
Posted: Oct 21, 2008 - 08:48
 

I have to somewhat agree with the poster below me.

Totally forgettable song.  I wish it would go off now, so I could forget it.

*Edit.*  I do love the band name tho.


Manbird
(Santa Rosa, CA)
Posted: Oct 18, 2008 - 18:53
 



scruzer
(Lompico, CA, USA)
Posted: Sep 19, 2008 - 17:21
 

 CanyonMan wrote:
And I don't think it has anything to do with gay lovers, that's silly...
 
For you it's silly — for me it's refreshing to hear a man sing of his relationship with another man.

Have some respect for the rest of us.


Wasted
Posted: Sep 19, 2008 - 17:17
 

Whether the lyrics were originally written from a woman's perspective or not, it still comes off as a story about a guy and his boyfriend...  and I like it that way.

springsmermaid
Posted: Sep 19, 2008 - 17:12
 

His voice sounds a lot like Bob Schneider, even the vocal styling.  Right?

CanyonMan
Posted: Jul 18, 2008 - 12:59
 

I'm lukewarm about it musically, but it's got some profound lyrics. Especially the parts toward the end about youthful idealism and disillusionment:

"He stepped on his dreams so many times and wore out the path he needed to take to find the life he thought would just happen to him like the changing of a season."



And I don't think it has anything to do with gay lovers, that's silly...it's just a man singing lyrics written for a woman singer.
aflanigan
(circling the drain)
Posted: Jul 18, 2008 - 12:59
 

ch83575 wrote:


Boyfriend songs are fairly common, but not ones sung by dudes. Those are indeed a pretty rare breed in popular music. I have nothing at all against a gay love-song, but this doesn't feel like that to me. It feels like a cover that they didn't even think about the words before singing... when he says he is a "flowergirl" I snicker every time. Perhaps I am wrong, but I still didn't much care for it.


I don't think you can automatically assume this song is written from a gay man's perspective simply because the vocalist is a man. Perhaps the man who penned the lyrics simply wanted to write from a female perspective (see Son of a Preacher Man, e.g.) Maybe it was originally written with a female singer in mind but she turned it down.

Although the tendency these days is to regender song lyrics as necessary (see Please Mister Postman, for example), it was not unheard of (particularly in Bluegrass music, I believe) for male or female singers to sing the lyrics of songs as written even if they were singing a song written from an opposite gender point of view.

I don't think of this song as primarily a love song, anyway; more of a lament on the inevitable loss of youthful idealism and optimism.
Photo-John
(Nor Cal to SLC)
Posted: Jul 18, 2008 - 12:40
 

Wow. That was really horrible.
old_shep
(Iowa)
Posted: Jul 18, 2008 - 12:40
 

Puke.
sirrus
(Fredneck, MD)
Posted: Jul 18, 2008 - 12:40
 

I don't get it. Why does everyone assume this is a personal (gay) story?

If Ian Anderson can sing from the perspective of a horse and Imogen Heap can sing from the perspective of a locust, why can't Huffamoose sing from the perspective of a (flower)girl?
esweazey73
Posted: Jul 18, 2008 - 12:39
 

What .?
ch83575
Posted: May 16, 2008 - 13:44
 

scruzer wrote:
"boyfriends" songs are rare! Thanks Bill!!!


Boyfriend songs are fairly common, but not ones sung by dudes. Those are indeed a pretty rare breed in popular music. I have nothing at all against a gay love-song, but this doesn't feel like that to me. It feels like a cover that they didn't even think about the words before singing... when he says he is a "flowergirl" I snicker every time. Perhaps I am wrong, but I still didn't much care for it.
Kilroy
Posted: May 16, 2008 - 13:42
 

So much for subtlety....

I don't like it when a male singer waxes obsequiously over a woman.... doing it over another man is just as bad.
rockasaurus
Posted: May 16, 2008 - 13:40
 

d00kie wrote:
meh


Double meh
vit
Posted: May 16, 2008 - 13:40
 

wow this song rocks so little I can't believe it's actually music.
d00kie
(In Cubicle Hell!)
Posted: May 16, 2008 - 13:39
 

meh
anniebear
(chapel hill, nc)
Posted: May 16, 2008 - 13:39
 

scruzer wrote:
"boyfriends" songs are rare! Thanks Bill!!!
I know, and thats a BIG part of why I am loving this!!!!
Manbird
(Santa Rosa, CA)
Posted: May 16, 2008 - 13:38
 


auburntigerrich
(Edge of the 'Verse)
Posted: May 16, 2008 - 13:37
 

I'm not actually listening right now, but...

Best... band name... ever.
Marr
(Houston (dreaming of Austin))
Posted: May 16, 2008 - 13:37
 

This is a cover, but I can't remember who did the original. Anyone?
Excelsior
Posted: May 16, 2008 - 13:37
 

:puke:
anniebear
(chapel hill, nc)
Posted: May 16, 2008 - 13:37
 

I LIKE this!
kaz
(click 'Support RP' above + cough up something!)
Posted: Apr 15, 2008 - 01:20
 

Particularly nice segue (probably) coming up to "Anna Ternheim - Today Is Such A Good Day"...
oscar_driver
(Planet Earth)
Posted: Mar 20, 2008 - 20:11
 

mefrombrazil wrote:

WHY DO YOU MAKE THIS QUESTION?


..... man i can't hear yooooou, you're screammmmmming!
scruzer
(Lompico, CA, USA)
Posted: Mar 14, 2008 - 13:38
 

"boyfriends" songs are rare! Thanks Bill!!!
mefrombrazil
(ponta grossa, brazil)
Posted: Mar 14, 2008 - 13:37
 

oscar_driver wrote:
hummm are they boyfriends?




WHY DO YOU MAKE THIS QUESTION?
oscar_driver
(Planet Earth)
Posted: Mar 14, 2008 - 13:36
 

hummm are they boyfriends?



Pyro
Posted: Mar 14, 2008 - 13:35
 

I like it. Thanks, Rirry.
mefrombrazil
(ponta grossa, brazil)
Posted: Mar 14, 2008 - 13:34
 

i prefer the band JAMES, not just the song JAMES.
xc_para_puravida
Posted: Mar 14, 2008 - 13:33
 


joeheyming
(Sunnyvale, CA)
Posted: Jan 11, 2008 - 14:58
 

Monotone
thejake
Posted: Jan 11, 2008 - 14:55
 

Made me take off my headphones. I don't like taking off my headphones.



princeofpeoria wrote:


i second that...once again


aflanigan
(Not far from Bedford Falls)
Posted: Jan 11, 2008 - 14:54
 

A great anthem about the disillusionment of having to grow up. Thanks for reviving this one.
lily34
(derby, ny)
Posted: Dec 11, 2007 - 05:12
 

woooohoo!! this hasn't been played in years (before october of this year.

thanks bill! love this band, love this cd.
Bocephus
(Boulder, CO)
Posted: Oct 09, 2007 - 09:17
 

sounds like a drunken Counting Crows. Yick.
princeofpeoria
(tulsa, OK)
Posted: May 08, 2003 - 19:12
 

Originally Posted by jplov:
not a fan...makes me want to change the station..........for 3 or 4 minutes


i second that...once again